This apple pie is about as epic as apple pie can be. I was known for it in some circles around campus back in college; in fact I even snagged a husband with it. I made it for Scott way back when we were ‘simply friends’. He told me later he was thinking, “I could make that apple pie with you forever.” Not too long after that, we started dating and I ended up making it almost once a month for him and his coworkers at his campus job; grounds crew. After a hot day of hard work, a slice of apple pie with a scoop of ice cream just hits the spot. Everyone used to call it Christy Kyle’s apple piles, but my last name has changed. How about Christy Jean’s Apple Pie?!
It is a fairly simple recipe as far as apple pies go, after all, how much cooking supplies does one own in college? I didn’t have a bunch of fancy ingredients either so I kept it simple, and simple goodness was created.
Just get a pack of deep dish pie shells (1 pack comes with 2, and from having tried them all, Pillsbury is worth the couple extra cents).
Mix up some flour, sugar, cinnamon, and vanilla. Peel and cut up 3-4 golden delicious apples (the greener the better, & don’t try substituting granny smith, golden delicious is the way to go for this pie), and mix apples with sugar mix. Sandwich the goodness between 2 pie shells and pinch edges together.
Spread a mixture of butter and brown sugar over the top after 40-45 minutes then bake for 10 more minutes. BAM, you have yourself a dangerously delicious pie!
There is a little liquid in the bottom you will see after you cut into it, though it turns into a syrup texture after it cools to room temp. You can add a couple more tablespoons of flour or cornstarch to the recipe to reduce the liquid amount, but I don’t because I absolutely love it! I literally call it ooey-gooey-goodness. It is so good drizzled over a scoop of ice cream or simply eaten with the pie.
- 2 deep dish pie shells
- 4 golden delicious apples
- ¾ cup white sugar
- 1 tbls cinnamon
- 2 tsp vanilla
- 2 tbls flour
- 1 tbls butter
- 2 tbls brown sugar
- Preheat oven to 400 degrees F
- Mix sugar, flour, and cinnamon. Mix in vanilla, mashing into mixture as much as possible
- Peel and cut up apples then mix in with sugar mixture.
- Pour mixture into one of the pie shells.
- Take other pie shell out of aluminum. This is easier if it has been out of the freezer 5-15 minutes. Too hard or frozen and it cracks, too thawed and it sticks. Put this shell on top of the other pie shell and cut 4-5 slits in the top to let steam rise out in the baking process.
- Cover edges of pie with three, 3 to 4 inch strips of aluminum foil, folding over edges. Do not cover center of pie because steam needs to escape.
- Bake for 45 minutes.
- Mix butter and brown sugar together. After taking pie out of oven at 45 minutes, take aluminum foil off and spread butter/sugar mix over pie (I use my fingers or a spoon).
- Bake for 10 more minutes, and done.